BYU Football

#2 BYU @ UCF: Beyond the Box Stat Preview

Notre Dame In Review Where BYU Beat Notre Dame So what do the stats say about this UCF team? The UCF Offense The UCF Defense The Matchup Let's tie it up

Notre Dame In Review

Well ladies and gentlemen, THEY DID IT! BYU pulled off the stunning upset in what is unquestionably the biggest game many of us have ever witnessed at LaVell Edwards Stadium! The rolling Cougs are 6-0 for the third straight year and come in at #2 in the AP Poll! They snapped a 16-game Notre Dame winning streak and unquestionably defeated the Fighting Irish.

2026 BYU Quality and EPA metrics
2026 BYU Explosive and Success Metrics

Last week, I stated that I thought Notre Dame was “ELITE“, that they were the more talented team. And it has never felt so good to be wrong. BYU proved that they have what it takes to go toe to toe with the upper echelon of College Football this year.

Because this was such a huge game, I’d be remiss if I didn’t take a bit extra time in this article explaining some more of the specifics from a statistical perspective, just how BYU won this game.

(Quick note for this section of the article, the Notre Dame game’s stats are raw, single-game numbers. Non-garbage time only, scrimmage plays only with penalties and kneeldowns taken out. I will compare this to Notre Dame’s raw numbers from the first 6 games of their season for comparison’s sake. This is very atypical my my usual stats, but I want to explain just how out of the norm this BYU team was able to perform against this talented Notre Dame team.)

Where BYU Beat Notre Dame

A comparison of how BYU’s offense and defense performed against Notre Dame in their games prior to BYU.

Before this past Saturday, Notre Dame’s offense came into the game averaging an insane 56.9% Early Down Success Rate and their floor in any individual game this season was 48%. BYU held them to just 32.7% in this metric. That’s not just “a little” better than their prior competition, that’s an entirely different tier.

Not surprisingly, this is essentially how the game turned out. Notre Dame needed to come back and make some critical clutch plays to even have a shot at winning this game, despite BYU’s struggles in the 3rd quarter. Notre Dame’s offense faced 19 third-downs on Saturday. The most it had faced in a single game prior to that was 11 against UNC. BYU’s defense forced four three-and-outs when they came into the game with just five combined in their previous 6 games.

I also said last week that “BYU needed to fit runs to a T” and boy did they. Notre Dame came into the game averaging 54.3% Rush Success and was held to just 34.5% by this stout BYU defense. Jonaz Walton who had over 400 yards combined in his two prior games had just 5 carries for 17 yards and was largely a non-factor in this game.

SEVEN, not THREE

This is one of the areas that I am most pleased with. Against Notre Dame, BYU had 4 total Eckel Drives. An Eckel is a “quality drive”. A drive in which you either score on offense OR you have a 1st down inside your opponent’s 40 yard line. All four of the BYU Eckel Drives ended in a touchdown. BYU didn’t need to attempt a FG all night. That is 7.0 Points Per Eckel against a defense that was only giving up 4.83 on average.

On the flip side, Notre Dame had SEVEN Eckel Drives and only walked away with two total touchdowns. They kicked three FGs, fumbled on a spike play and failed to convert on the final drive of the game to beat BYU resulting in an average of 3.43 Points Per Eckel. BYU forced the Fighting Irish to settle and did no such thing themselves.

Last Week’s Keys

Last week, I gave six keys I thought would be instrumental in architecting an upset, let’s check in on those.

  1. Win the turnover Battle (+2 or better): Grade D
    BYU lost the turnover battle -1 and still was able to find a way to win this game.
  2. Win on First Down: Grade A
    You can see in the table above. BYU had a 40% First Down Success Rate against a team averaging allowing just 26.6% and held the ND offense to just 36.7% on the other side of the ball. BYU largely won 1st down on both sides of the ball.
  3. Use Bear’s legs wisely: Grade A
    I had said that we probably needed 12-15 well-timed carries from Bear while we missed LJ Martin and he finished the game with 13 carries for 45 yards with a 54% Success Rate and two rushing scores. 7/13 came on plays inside the Notre Dame 15, right where you want them to be. Bear also added the 15 yard touchdown reception on the double-pass from Kyler Kasper that was a hat-tip to the Jaren Hall touchdown reception in 2022 against then #9 Baylor.
  4. Take Calculated Shots: Grade A-
    BYU had 7 explosive plays (10.6% of snaps) against a defense that was averaging allowing one on just 6.7%. Each of those passes was thrown within 20 yards of the line of scrimmage and turned into a huge chunk play after the catch. Lyons, Glasker (x2), Kyler, and Bear all had explosive receptions on the day. This is precisely what I meant when I said “get the ball to your skilled guys quick and let them get some YAC”. I would have given this an A if that 39-yard Jojo Phillips touchdown didn’t get called back due to OPI.
  5. SEVEN not Three: Grade A+
    Four Eckel Drives. Four Touchdowns. Zero Field Goals. You can’t beat that type of efficiency in quality territory.
  6. Bonus: Steal a possession on special teams. Grade D (with a redemption arc)
    A muffed punt gave Notre Dame the ball at the BYU 40 yard line and a failed fake-punt on 4th and 5 from the BYU 28 gave Notre Dame two free quality possessions that they were only able to turn into Field Goals. The redemption arc to me, though, came when Cannon DeVries, after muffing the punt earlier kept his chin up and returned a 60 yard punt back 23 yards to the BYU 45 yard line setting up the game-winning touchdown drive. This was a huge play for DeVries who hopefully put the ball on the ground for the last time.

What almost caused a different result

I want to be completely fair and honest here. There is an alternate universe where BYU loses this game and we’re talking about the exact same handful of plays that did it. The only things that kept Notre Dame in this game were self-inflicted mistakes and some extremely lopsided 4th down play.

Hats off to the whole BYU team, they truly earned what in my opinion is the biggest win in Modern BYU history and it was not a “fluky” win. The next test will be doing it again on the road at a scrappy-but-rested UCF Knights team.

If you’re not a member of CougConnect, what are you doing? Subscribe today and get on with helping these student athletes through grassroots NIL. If you do, make sure you join the Discord and come chat with the thousands of fans that talk about everything and anything BYU. They seriously are (in my biased opinion) the best group of Cougs on the internet!

(From here on out in the article, we’ll go back to the stats I post being opponent-adjusted, excluding garbage time and games against FCS opponents. Unless I say otherwise, you can assume everything below adheres to that)

So what do the stats say about this UCF team?

UCF is 3-3 (1-2 in Big 12 play) and is #72 in my personal “most-deserving” rankings. They are coming off of a much needed bye and Scott Frost and company have had 2 weeks to prepare to give BYU everything they’ve got. This is setting up to be a textbook “trap game”. That being said, though, the team seems like it is focused. They’ve gotten “got” by this type of game before. “The dud after the emotional victory”. We can hope that the team has already turned the page over their emotional win and is ready for the back half of their schedule.

2026 Quality and EPA stats for UCF.
2026 Explosive and Success metrics for UCF.

At a glance, UCF appears to be a team with a somewhat poor offense and a defense that can be a bit stingy at times. But our model projects a roughly 27-22 victory for BYU. For the first time in a while, the model is less optimistic about BYU than the market is.

The UCF Offense

They tend to find paydirt in quality territory… but aren’t consistent enough. I personally think it might be their line. UCF has some absolute speedsters at RB, but their woes seem like they start up front. UCF is #119 in the country in Stuff Rate and #119 in Line Yards Per Rush. So far this year, 22% of UCF’s runs have gone for 0 or less yards. Another 37 have gone for just 1-3. This is how they end up at #113 in Standard Down Success Rate and constantly playing in obvious passing downs. UCF is averaging 3rd and 7+ on third downs this season and have barely over a 33% 3rd down conversion rate.

2021-2026 UCF Stuff Rate rankings

The work is going to be cut out for UCF as BYU is statistically excellent in those respective stats and has an extremely stout run defense.

The UCF Defense

The UCF defense tends to bend bend bend… and then… doesn’t break? Is that really true with what we’ve seen from the last few games? This is sure to be an interesting matchup for BYU when you look at just how well opponents have moved the ball on UCF.

2021-2026 UCF 3rd Down Success Rate rankings
2021-2026 UCF Three-and-out Rate rankings

The “Don’t break” part:

2021-2026 UCF Points Per Eckel rankings

Of 33 Opponent Eckel Drives on the season so far (non-garbage time) just 11 have resulted in a touchdown. Of the remaining 22, 9 ended in Field Goals (plus another missed FG), they forced 4 turnovers and 3 turnovers on downs.

A chart detailing a few of the stats from UCF’s game’s to date

But this is the part that I think matters the most. Their “don’t break” mantra hasn’t seemed to be holding in the last two weeks against offenses with firepower (of which BYU is certainly one). Maybe their bye helps to fix some of this leakage that they are experiencing these last two games.

The Matchup

Head to Head comparison of BYU vs UCF in the metrics, offense vs defense
Biggest ranking-gaps from the matchup above – Offense
Biggest ranking-gaps from the matchup above – Defense

The model thinks that this game is going to be a close ~5-6 point game for BYU. But I am finding myself thinking the opposite. BYU’s players have gone on record saying they’ve had the emotional let downs in prior seasons, and they are motivated and focused to make sure that doesn’t impact anything moving forward. I believe them. And the metrics above paint a pretty clear picture for me. BYU plays the “efficiency” game and stays on schedule. UCF’s inability to counter that in weeks-past is going to be a tough out for them in this matchup.

So far on the season, UCF has been a pretty abysmal 2nd half team going from averaging 0.22 EPA Per Play in the first half to just 0.03 in the 2nd half. Some of it is game-script and some of it is the defense being on the field for 66 snaps per game (5th most in FBS) and running out of gas.

I personally think this game is going to be a blowout. You have a BYU team that has discovered its tough identity against Notre Dame who is determined to make a statement and defend their #2 ranking. This UCF team is a perfect team for them to do this against. They can play the type of ball they want to play and dictate the game by going on long drives and controlling the ball. It genuinely wouldn’t surprise me to see BYU win the time of possession battle in this game 40:00 to 20:00.

My projection for the game is a huge BYU win, 44-17 with the final UCF touchdown coming in garbage time against backups on BYU’s team.

Let’s tie it up

BYU is the better team. If BYU can demonstrate that they won’t have a letdown game after such an emotional and one of the biggest wins in program history, I think they cruise to victory. UCF has had two weeks to prepare and genuinely nothing to lose. I think the only way BYU loses this game is if they show up and play like they’ve already won it. So let’s get into my keys.

You can find me on X/Twitter @m4gbit and hanging out in the CougConnect Discord!

Don’t forget to Subscribe to CougConnect, it’s going to be another great week to be a Cougar fan!

Go Cougs!