BYU QB McCae Hillstead joins the CougConnect podcast to break down his football journey—from his days growing up in Springville to starting at Utah State, transferring to BYU, and battling for the starting spot in 2025. He opens up about injuries, recruiting struggles, what makes him unique as a QB, and who’s standing out in BYU’s loaded WR room.
🔥 Jump to Highlights
🧑🎓 Early Football Journey
➡️ [00:00–03:30]
How McCae went from Springville to starting three years at Skyridge, switching positions, and finding his passion for QB play.
🏈 Recruiting & Injury Setbacks
➡️ [03:30–06:50]
Undersized, overlooked, and injured—but still led his team to a state title and earned a shot at Utah State.
📈 Breakout at Utah State
➡️ [06:50–08:45]
Made the most of limited opportunities, set a freshman passing record (399 yards), and learned what it takes to play at the next level.
🔁 The Transfer Portal & BYU Decision
➡️ [09:00–11:20]
Why McCae entered the portal, what led him to BYU, and how it came down to the Cougars vs. Utes.
💪 His Strengths as a QB
➡️ [13:00–15:10]
What separates McCae: fast release, playmaking instincts, and being a “jack of all trades” in A-Rod’s system.
🤝 Vibes in the QB Room
➡️ [18:00–19:15]
No drama—just competition, friendship, and a united focus on a Big 12 title.
🧃 WRs Turning Heads
➡️ [19:30–21:15]
Names to watch – WR’s to keep an eye on
⚡ Speed Kills: Reggie Can Fly
➡️ [21:15–22:15]
McCae confirms: Reggie is top-3 in every acceleration test and can stretch a defense like few can.
📏 Playing Undersized & QB Tips
➡️ [23:00–26:30]
Insight for undersized QBs: why size doesn’t define success and how to work through throwing lanes and blind reads.
🍦 Creamery vs. Aggie Ice Cream
➡️ [29:30]
BYU Creamery wins by default. No mint slander allowed.
🏟️ Spectrum vs. Marriott Center
➡️ [31:00]
Spectrum’s rowdy, but Big 12 ball and the Marriott Center take the crown.
👀 Final Message to Cougar Nation
➡️ [33:06]
The team is dialed. The goal? Big 12 title and a shot at the playoff.
